The Bull

Wednesday 22

October, 201412:32 AM

Industry Chart

TheBull PREMIUM

  • Trading
  • &
  • Technical
  • Analysis

Property bubble? That's the theory, anyway

Property bubble? That's the theory, anyway

By Expert Panel 12.08.2013


By Philip Soos, Deakin University

As Australian housing prices have boomed over the last decade and a half, there has been much discussion over whether a bubble exists in the residential property market. More recently, the concern is the record-low interest rate of 2.5% may cause a housing bubble.

Conspicuously absent in the debate over the housing bubble within the mass media is a clear definition of what constitutes a bubble. This is not only the fault of the media, as a bubble is often vaguely defined within the academic literature, usually on the basis of “irrational exuberance” or “animal spirits” or chasing capital gains, rather than in terms of specific and measurable metrics.

An outside observer may find this difficult to believe, particularly given the history of regular booms and busts in the land and share markets, as recent events in the US, Ireland and Spain have shown. Mainstream economists typically claim bubbles can only be recognised in hindsight, but not identified beforehand.

Without a concrete definition, it is impossible to find something because one does not know what to look for. It is similar to telling a blind person to choose the blue pill instead of the red. Accordingly, how can a reasonable definition of a bubble be determined?

In search of a definition

One economist did provide a straightforward definition of an asset bubble: Hyman Minsky. He belonged to the post-Keynesian school of economic thought, a heterodox school with an alternative theory of how financial markets and the banking system interacts with assets, typically shares and real estate.

One of the centrepieces of Minsky’s work is the “Financial Instability Hypothesis” (FIH) which argues financial markets are intrinsically chaotic and inefficient, eventually sowing the seeds of their own destruction. According to the FIH, a bubble is defined on the basis of how an asset class is financed.

This is important, as it allows us to assess whether overvaluation exists within any particular asset class, or in this case, real estate. According to Minsky, the state of financing can be described as either hedge, speculative, or Ponzi.

With hedge financing, asset income flows are sufficient to pay down both principal and interest on the debt used to finance the asset purchase, and prices are based upon fundamental or intrinsic value. The second state is speculative finance, where income flows cover only interest repayments but not principal, requiring debt to be continually rolled over from the current time period to the next.

The terminal phase is that of Ponzi finance, as income flows cover neither principal nor interest repayments. This leaves owners completely reliant upon escalating asset values to realise substantial capital gains upon sale to meet the cost of debt and expenses. In the case of real estate, if property investors can’t profit from rental income, then realising capital gains becomes the only avenue.

As investors speculate, the debt used for asset purchases inevitably rises as both the cause and response to price increases, creating a positive feedback loop between prices and debt. Put simply, for the residential property market to meet Minsky’s definition of a bubble, three conditions must be met: increases in real (inflation-adjusted) housing prices and mortgage debt, along with persistent rental income losses.

Three conditions of a bubble

There is evidence to show all three conditions exist. From the trough in 1996 to the apparent peak in 2010, real housing prices increased nationwide by 123%, the mortgage debt to GDP ratio rose from 35% to 87% over the same period, and from 2001 onwards, aggregate rental income could not cover running expenses and interest repayments on aggregate, let alone principal.

(It’s worth pointing out that Australia’s negative gearing policy amplifies aggregate rental income losses by providing an incentive for investors to run their properties at a loss while expecting capital gains. Investors should not be profiting from capital gains but long-term rental income. While it can be argued negative gearing is an unjustified subsidy (tax expenditure), it should be banned on the basis that it amplifies financial instability through helping to create asset bubbles.)

 

 

 

 

 

 

Minsky’s FIH has some predictive power as the data shows all three conditions were met during the late 1980s, as a small residential bubble arose on the back of a colossal commercial real estate bubble. Real housing prices increased by 39% between 1987 and the peak in 1989, before falling 8% by 1991. The mortgage debt to GDP ratio also increased during this period, and aggregate rental income was negative from 1989 to 1992.

There are eight measures of property valuation that show a substantial increase since 1996, collectively peaking in 2010. They are: nominal prices to inflation, mortgage debt to GDP ratio, rental income flows, gross yields (or P/E ratio), price to income ratio, Kavanagh-Putland Index (aggregate property sales to GDP ratio), aggregate land values to GDP ratio, and housing stock value to GDP ratio.

Bubbles don’t exist

There are two primary reasons why definitions of bubbles aren’t used in the mass media and academia. Self-interest is the obvious motivation; Australia’s residential property market has a bubble in prices, creating around $2 trillion in paper (phantom) wealth. This has made the finance, insurance and real estate (FIRE) sector fabulously wealthy, and government at all levels have benefited from rising property taxes.

Mainstream economists don’t like the idea of bubbles because the highly unrealistic theory they teach to promote policies of privatisation, deregulation and liberalisation have resulted in the largest asset bubbles in history, in direct conflict of the allegedly efficient outcomes markets supposedly create. When theory and the real world conflict in economics departments, data are dismissed because it doesn’t fit the models.

The doctrines of conventional economic theory – such as equilibrium, rational expectations and optimising behaviour – are empirically false. Economists’ models of markets are like that of an astronomer who creates an incorrect model of the solar system by excluding the sun and moons. Given the deleterious state of economy theory, it should come as little surprise the economics profession cannot identify colossal asset bubbles right in front of them.

Elite Harvard-MIT-Princeton economists in the US not only missed the obvious dot-com and housing bubbles, but put a significant amount of effort into denying these bubbles existed. On this basis, there is little hope for Australian economists, especially for those who work for government and the FIRE sector.

In the debate over the housing market, it is important for those who have vested and conflicts of interest to avoid using definitions of an asset bubble so as to create confusion regarding this matter. Further, it is difficult to claim the presently low interest rates could risk causing a housing bubble when it is readily apparent one has existed since 2001.

Philip Soos does not work for, consult to, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has no relevant affiliations.

The Conversation

This article was originally published at The Conversation.



FROM THE NEWSLETTER

Seeking Safety in High Yield Stocks

We searched the ASX for dividend paying stocks... More

Abbott's G20 agenda: climate still the elephant in the room

To date, the Australian government has made it... More

The 10 Biggest Energy Company Bankruptcies

Here are the bankruptcies that will be etched... More

Stocks on a roll: ASX rolling 52-week highs

ASX rolling 52-week highs for the previous... More



WHAT’S ON THIS WEEK

week 24 October 2014
    • 20
    • Medibank Private prospectus Finance Minister Mathias Cormann and Medibank Private managing director George Savvides announce details of Medibank Private prospectus | 4:05 AM
    • RBA Speech by RBA assistant governor (Economic) Christopher Kent to the Leading Age Services Australia National Congress 2014 | 6:08 AM
    • SGH Slater & Gordon annual general meeting | 6:09 AM
    • Book launch Book launch of The Boy From Nowhere, the story of Kerry Stokes | 6:46 AM
    • 21
    • RBA Minutes of Reserve Bank of Australia October board meeting released | 2:18 AM
    • SXL Southern Cross Austereo annual general meeting | 2:18 AM
    • RBA Speech by RBA deputy governor Philip Lowe to the Commonwealth Bank's Australasian Fixed Income conference | 4:29 AM
    • NCM Newcrest Mining quarterly production report | 4:59 AM
    • International Investment Funds Association Annual Conference of the International Investment Funds Association | 5:13 AM
    • BKN Bradken annual general meeting | 5:16 AM
    • ABS Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) International merchandise imports for September | 5:41 AM
    • ANZ ANZ-Roy Morgan weekly consumer confidence survey | 5:42 AM
    • QAN Qantas chief executive Alan Joyce to unveil new A330 business suite | 5:42 AM
    • 22
    • Australia-Israel Chamber of Commerce lunch Former ACCC chairman Graeme Samuel speaking at Australia-Israel Chamber of Commerce lunch | 4:06 AM
    • SUL Super Retail Group annual general meeting | 5:13 AM
    • CBA Commonwealth Bank Business Sales Indicator for September | 5:35 AM
    • ORG Origin Energy annual general meeting | 5:40 AM
    • Westpac/Melbourne Institute Westpac-Melbourne Institute Leading Indexes of Economic Activity | 6:05 AM
    • ABS ABS Consumer Price Index for September quarter | 6:05 AM
    • BHP BHP Billiton quarterly production report | 6:06 AM
    • Northern Territory Major Projects Conference Northern Territory Major Projects Conference | 6:09 AM
    • AmCham lunch Twitter Australia managing director Karen Stocks speaking at AmCham lunch | 6:10 AM
    • 23
    • HIA Housing Industry Association-RP Data residential land report for the June quarter | 2:19 AM
    • AGL AGL annual general meeting | 4:23 AM
    • SKE Skilled Group annual general meeting | 4:24 AM
    • TOL Toll Holdings annual general meeting | 4:25 AM
    • AMC Amcor annual general meeting | 4:25 AM
    • BKL Blackmores annual general meeting | 4:26 AM
    • IOF Investa Office Fund annual general meeting | 4:26 AM
    • NAB National Australia Bank's business survey for the September quarter | 4:28 AM
    • BHP BHP Billiton annual general meeting | 4:29 AM
    • RBA RBA governor Glenn Stevens to address annual general meeting of the Australian Payments and Clearing Association | 6:07 AM
    • SUN Suncorp Group annual general meeting | 6:08 AM
    • 24
    • QAN Qantas annual general meeting | 4:26 AM
    • PPX PaperlinX annual general meeting | 4:27 AM
    • QFX Quickflix annual general meeting | 4:27 AM
    • CRZ Carsales.com annual general meeting | 4:27 AM
    • RMD Resmed first quarter results | 4:28 AM

TheBull.com.au

TheBull.com.au

TheBull PREMIUM article search

STOCK QUOTE

Don't know the company code? Click here



Featured Comment

Craig James, of CommSec points out that retail sales grew by 7.4 per cent during the past year, marking the best rolling 12-month period since January 2002

Festive season stocks handpicked by leading brokers

Broker buys

  • ASX Code
  • Company
  • Broker
  • TPMTPG TelecomCalibre
  • VEDVeda GroupCalibre
  • LLCLend LeaseAlpha Securities
  • MQGMacquarieAlpha Securities
  • OSHOil SearchPhillipCapital
  • CWNCrown ResortsPhillipCapital

Broker sells

  • ASX Code
  • Company
  • Broker
  • MINMineral ResourcesCalibre
  • AGOAtlas IronCalibre
  • MYRMyerAlpha Securities
  • CCLCoca-Cola AmatilAlpha Securities
  • QANQantasPhillipCapital
  • MINMineral ResourcesPhillipCapital

Central Banks Rates

  • RBA2.50%
  • FED0.25%
  • BOE0.50%
  • BOC1.00%
  • RBNZ3.25%
  • ECB0.15%
  • SNB0.00%
  • BOJ0.10%

Upcoming dividends

  • ASX Code
  • Company, Div., Franking
  • Ex-Div.

Eight brokers like these stocks

  • ASX Code
  • Company Name
  • Consensus Target
  • DOWDowner EDI Limited$5.78
  • FMGFortescue Metals Grp Ltd$6.89
  • ORAOrora Limited$1.51
  • RIORio Tinto Limited$81.22
  • CSLCSL Limited$73.30

Upcoming Floats

  • ASX Code
  • Company Name
  • Float Date

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR SPONSORS, AUSTRALIA'S LEADING BROKERS:



© Copyright The Compare Group Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.