The Bull

Sunday 23

November, 2014 9:46 PM

Industry Chart


  • Trends
  • &
  • Opportunities

8 Stocks at Rock-Bottom Prices

8 Stocks at Rock-Bottom Prices

By Bob Kohut 04.02.2012

Bottom trawling has always been an attractive investment strategy for many newcomers to share market investing.  They quickly learn from some of the world’s greatest investors that the key is to buy low and sell high.  The core idea of bottom trawling is casting your net in the hopes of finding shares so low they appear to have hit bottom with nowhere to go but up.

Regardless of whether an investor searches the 52 week rolling low daily lists, or for shares with very low P/E ratios, the hidden reef in bottom trawling is the fact the bottom can keep dropping.  How low can it go?  

There are three potential outcomes to bottom trawling:

1.    You can be right and the share price begins to recover overt time.
2.    You can be early and the share price continues to drop.
3.    You can be wrong and the share price fails to recover.
Note that two of those outcomes carry the risk of breaking a cardinal rule of many investors – don’t lose money.  Some investors convince themselves a share can recover and regain its 52 week high.  In the belief they got in early, they continue to buy as the shares drop, averaging down their cost per share.  

There are few examples of the dangers of bottom trawling better than the demise of an iconic American investment bank – Lehman Brothers.  The CEO of the firm insisted they were fine and the share price drop was largely due to short-selling.  You know the end of the story.

However, there are success stories with bottom trawling as well.  On 11 September 2011 Australians learned of a voluntary recall from industry leader Cochlear (COH) of its latest implant line, the Nucleus CI500 implants.  The share price plunged to a new 52 week low.  A major concern expressed by analysts was loss of market share.  As often happens with shares in decline, COH continued to make new 52 week lows over the next month.  The following 6 month share price movement chart shows what happened next:

Cochlear is still far from its pre-recall highs, but the share price began to recover quickly, although modestly.  This pattern is not typical of most shares in a bottoming trend.  Low P/E ratios and share price reaching or approaching 52 week lows are indications the collective judgment of share market participants is the future of the company is not bright.  It takes time to alter perceptions.  One of the keys to successful bottom trawling is patience.  Another is faith in the markets and in shares as investment vehicles that pay superior returns in the long run, as well as faith in the company in the bottoming trend.

BHP is the world’s largest diversified resources company and right now it is a candidate for bottom trawlers.  Its current P/E Ratio of 9.69 is below the ASX P/E of 12.28 and below the Materials Sector P/E of 11.64.  With a current share price of around $37, it is trading about 10% above its 52 week low of $33.68.  Let’s look at their one year chart:

BHP hit its 52 week high of $49.81 in early April of 2011 and it has been downhill since then.  In late September it reached the 52 week low and has revisited that level three times in the subsequent months.  Despite the downward slide, analysts from Macquarie, Citi, UBS, Credit Suisse, Deutsche Bank, and RBS Australia all have Buy or Outperform ratings on BHP as of early 2012.  BA-Merrill Lynch and JP Morgan have neutral ratings.

To make bottom trawling work for you there are several “safety valves” you can check to help estimate the chances the share you are considering will eventually bounce back.  Analyst opinion is one.  While some experienced retail investors might not care what the analyst community has to say, most of us get a measure of comfort knowing at least some analysts see the same rosier future we suspect might be there.  Here are all six safety valves:

1.    Dividends per Share (DPS)
2.    Return on Equity (ROE)
3.    Debt to Equity (Gearing(
4.    5 Year Average Annual Earnings per Share (EPS) growth
5.    5 Year Average Revenue per Share growth
6.    Analyst Opinion

The strategy begins with a list of target shares and then assessing each against the safety valve measures.  The simplest way to create a list is to use a stock screener looking for shares with P/E’s under 10 and P/EG’s less than 1.0.  The P/EG is in effect another safety check since it uses forward or projected earnings in its calculation.  A PEG of 1.00 in theory is perfectly priced with the share price matching the projected earnings.  Ratios under 1.0 tell us projected earnings per share are greater than the current share price.

Here are seven target shares that meet those criteria with the added measure of analyst recommendation.  Every share in the following table has at least one analyst with a Buy, Accumulate, or Outperform rating on the company:

Mkt Cap
52 Wk Hi/Lo
Current Share Price
Air New Zealand/AIZ
Henderson Grp/HGG $1,083M
Mt Gibson Iron/MGX 
Oakton Ltd/OKN
Nuplex Industries/NPX   
$372M  6.31  
BHP Biliton/BHP  
Rio Tinto/RIO   

Looking at these preliminary numbers you can see all are up from their 52 week lows, but none more than 20% up.  MGX appears to have the most attractive combination of P/E and P/EG but we need to look at the remaining safety valves.

Dividends per Share looks strictly at the amount paid without considering the share price of the company.  The six safety valves we are using are all independent of the daily price per share.  Dividend yield for shares at the bottom will be artificially high, since the share price is low.  

Return on Equity (ROE) is another measure of the inherent soundness of the company regardless of market perception as indicated by the share price.  ROE is a measure of how well a company uses what it owns (assets) to produce earnings.  Again, ROE has nothing to do with share price.  As you may know, an ROE at 15% or above is a health indicator for most business sectors.

Five year average annual growth rates for both revenue and earnings per share is an important safety check for bottom dwelling shares.  They tell us what the company has done in the past and while no guarantee they can repeat the performance, good companies generally repeat good performance over time, despite setbacks.

A low Debt to Equity Ratio (Gearing) tells us the company uses more of its own money rather than borrowed money to operate.  Companies with high debt and high gearing who find their share price falling dramatically may find it hard to borrow or to raise capital through issuing new shares.  

5 Yr Avg EPS Growth
5 Yr Avg Rev Growth
$.04 19.8%
3.9% 23.8% 21.1%
38.2%27.5%  10.1% 10.7%
 12.5% 11.6%


Air New Zealand along with consulting and technology company Oakton and industrial products manufacturer Nuplex are immediate candidates to be culled from the list.  Simply put, their growth performance over the last 5 years is sub-standard.  Remember, we are talking about safely bottom trawling.  Investors willing to tolerate higher risk should consider a number we deliberately eliminated – the 2 Year EPS Average Annual Growth Forecast.  You can find this number but as you know forecasts can be missed.  The 2 Year EPS Growth Forecast for AIZ is an astounding 108.2%.  Research them further if you will, but we think there are safer choices.

Rio and BHP are world renowned companies and it is hard to argue against their being long term holdings in any investment portfolio, especially at current prices.

Investment management services provider Henderson Group pays a respectable dividend with a solid ROE and acceptable growth over the last five years.  However, before investing we would further examine their financial statements regarding debt, as a debt to equity ratio of 50% may be a cause for concern.  For your information, HGG’s 2 year EPS forecast is for 40% average growth.

Mount Gibson Iron appears to us to be the safest choice.  Although their dividend is modest, their debt to equity, ROE and 5 Year growth rates are solid.  Their 2 Year forward projection is for 39.2% growth.  If you have been following the company, you know they missed estimates in December 2011.  Deutsche Bank maintained its Buy rating on 01 February, 2012 while dropping its price target.  RBS Australia downgraded the company from Buy to Hold on 27 January 2012.  Here is their share price movement over the last year:

Please note that simply publishes broker recommendations on this page. The publication of these recommendations does not in any way constitute a recommendation on the part of should seek professional advice before making any investment decisions.


Rise of corporate divorces leads to fleeting gains

For the global mergers and acquisitions market,... More

How do you give financial help to your adult children?

Most, who can, want to give financial help to... More

Eight Pitfalls in Evaluating Green Energy Solutions

Oil that was cheap to extract (say $20 barrel)... More

Stocks on a roll: ASX rolling 52-week highs

ASX rolling 52-week highs for the previous... More


week 28 November 2014
    • 24
    • BHP BHP Billiton briefing on its coal and copper businesses | 8:49 AM
    • Deloitte/Financial Services Council lunch David Murray, chair of the Financial System Inquiry, speaking at a Deloitte/Financial Services Council lunch | 8:50 AM
    • 25
    • AllianceBernstein economist Guy Bruten Briefing on Australian economy in 2015 by AllianceBernstein economist Guy Bruten | 4:23 AM
    • AOFM Australian Office of Financial Management (AOFM) to issue $200 million of February 21, 2022 Treasury Indexed Bonds | 4:25 AM
    • Australian British Chamber of Commerce lunch Helen Conway, director of Workplace Gender Equality Agency, speaking at Australian British Chamber of Commerce lunch | 5:42 AM
    • CEDA CEDA workplace flexibility event featuring PwC managing partner Gavin Moss | 6:46 AM
    • RBA Speech by Reserve Bank of Australia deputy governor Philip Lowe to the annual Australian Business Economists conference dinner | 8:48 AM
    • HVN Harvey Norman annual general meeting | 8:48 AM
    • MPL Medibank Private shares to begin trading on ASX | 8:48 AM
    • ALL Aristocrat Leisure full year results | 8:49 AM
    • ANZ ANZ-Roy Morgan weekly consumer confidence survey | 8:49 AM
    • BKN Brickworks annual general meeting | 8:50 AM
    • MSB Mesoblast annual general meeting | 8:51 AM
    • RFG Retail Food Group annual general meeting | 8:51 AM
    • 26
    • AOFM AOFM to issue $700 million of April 21, 2024 Treasury Bonds | 2:19 AM
    • ABS Australian Bureau of Statistics construction work done for September quarter | 4:25 AM
    • HIA Housing Industry Association/Commonwealth Bank affordability report for the September quarter | 4:27 AM
    • CAB Cabcharge annual general meeting | 5:22 AM
    • WEB Webjet annual general meeting | 5:22 AM
    • SUN Suncorp chief executive Patrick Snowball speaking at Australian British Chamber of Commerce lunch | 5:22 AM
    • AVG Australian Vintage annual general meeting | 6:08 AM
    • REX Regional Express annual general meeting | 6:09 AM
    • 27
    • AOFM AOFM to issue $500 million of Treasury Notes maturing on Febrary 27,2015 | 4:05 AM
    • ABS ABS private new capital expenditure and expected expenditure for the September quarter | 4:24 AM
    • HIA HIA new home sales for October | 4:27 AM
    • WOW Woolworths annual general meeting | 4:28 AM
    • CBA Commonwealth Bank business sales indicator for October | 4:28 AM
    • BOQ Bank of Queensland annual general meeting | 5:20 AM
    • SEK SEEK annual general meeting | 5:21 AM
    • MYX Mayne Pharma Group annual general meeting | 5:23 AM
    • BPT Beach Energy annual general meeting | 5:23 AM
    • FeTech magnetite and iron ore conference FeTech magnetite and iron ore conference | 5:41 AM
    • 28
    • RBA RBA to release financial aggregates for October | 4:26 AM
    • LYC Lynas Corp annual general meeting | 4:27 AM
    • MEL Metgasco annual general meeting | 4:28 AM
    • PRY Primary Health Care annual general meeting | 4:28 AM
    • RRL Regis Resources annual general meeting | 4:29 AM
    • AHF Australian Dairy Farms annual general meeting | 6:07 AM
    • AOFM AOFM to issue $500 million of October 21, 2019 Treasury Bonds | 6:09 AM
    • FeTech magnetite and iron ore conference FeTech magnetite and iron ore conference | 6:09 AM

TheBull PREMIUM article search


Don't know the company code? Click here

Featured Comment

The of tech floats last year looks more interesting than this year, partly because, for most of news listings, I like to watch how IPOs perform in the aftermarket before rushing in.

3 Standout Floats from 2013 that look good at current prices

Broker buys

  • ASX Code
  • Company
  • Broker
  • TPMTPG TelecomCalibre
  • VEDVeda GroupCalibre
  • LLCLend LeaseAlpha Securities
  • MQGMacquarieAlpha Securities
  • OSHOil SearchPhillipCapital
  • CWNCrown ResortsPhillipCapital

Broker sells

  • ASX Code
  • Company
  • Broker
  • MINMineral ResourcesCalibre
  • AGOAtlas IronCalibre
  • MYRMyerAlpha Securities
  • CCLCoca-Cola AmatilAlpha Securities
  • QANQantasPhillipCapital
  • MINMineral ResourcesPhillipCapital

Central Banks Rates

  • RBA2.50%
  • FED0.25%
  • BOE0.50%
  • BOC1.00%
  • RBNZ3.25%
  • ECB0.15%
  • SNB0.00%
  • BOJ0.10%

Upcoming dividends

  • ASX Code
  • Company, Div., Franking
  • Ex-Div.

Eight brokers like these stocks

  • ASX Code
  • Company Name
  • Consensus Target
  • DOWDowner EDI Limited$5.78
  • FMGFortescue Metals Grp Ltd$6.89
  • ORAOrora Limited$1.51
  • RIORio Tinto Limited$81.22
  • CSLCSL Limited$73.30

Upcoming Floats

  • ASX Code
  • Company Name
  • Float Date


© Copyright The Compare Group Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.